Question:
Can I get all the calcium my body needs from fruits and veggies alone?
2007-07-30 10:20:20 UTC
I'm not a dairy person and don't really drink alot of milk anymore, or any dairy for that matter.

And I was wondering wether calcium from fruits and veggies is as good as the calcium from milk

I checked online and it said an adult only need around 100 MG of calcium a day and:

1 apple = 9.5 mg
Banana = 7 MG
Black berries = 46 mg
grapes = 9 mg
Orange = 52 mg
tomato 31.9
watermelon = 23 mg

And there are some others
So wouldn't it be better to get your calcium off fruits and veggies since they have the calcium you need and plenty of other vitamins and minerals?

Or is the calcium in milk somewhat better?

Thanks
Ten answers:
blrnyboy
2007-07-30 10:35:33 UTC
Calcium from vegetables is not only adequate for your body's needs, it's more readily available to the body than the calcium in milk.



Some of the better sources of calcium are vegetables like broccoli (47mg per 100g serving) and cauliflower (22mg per 100g serving) as well as the ones you've listed. You can also get plenty of calcium from items like soy milk, calcium-fortified tofu, or calcium-fortified orange juice.



In my opinion there is no need to ever drink dairy. No matter what the commercials/pamphlets/lobbyists/etc say, dairy is not necessary for healthy bones.
Sunshine Swirl
2007-07-30 12:23:52 UTC
First off, vegans here and people in other countries that do not consume milk, get about 200 mg of calcium a day and have very little cases of osteoporosis. In addition, the natural calcium found in dark green leaves and veggies are accompanied by magnesium (another mineral great for helping calcium get absorbed), while cow's milk has to have it added after they have been milked and it isn't even enough!!
mr curious
2007-07-31 06:32:09 UTC
All the minerals you need are in fruits, veggies, beans, seeds and nuts. Remember that calcium alone is not going to help you. Cow Milk is actually causing calcium loss but if you eat something like kale, the calcium is ingested with other minerals and vitamins and is absorbed better.



Search here to get more info on calcium

http://tinyurl.com/3834qq
Am
2007-07-30 10:40:37 UTC
Yes, but I would still advise taking vitamins and fortified foods that way you're not stressing your self out counting all the intake you are trying to get to meet the quota each day lol



BTW calcium in milk is the worst b/c it has a property that leaches protein from you in the long run, sure it has calcium but it also leaches calcium. That is one reason people shouldn't drink more then 3 glasses of milk a day if that. It's a lie that milk is the holy grale of calcium.
al l
2007-07-30 20:02:03 UTC
You can get calcium in plenty of places. It really doesn't matter so long as you get the calcium but keep in mind milk is high in fat. Here is a web site with a list of foods containing calcium.
KathyS
2007-07-30 10:53:54 UTC
The average adult needs about 1000 mgs a day and that's for ages 19-50.



Other great sources include broccoli, spinach, almonds.
Gordi
2007-07-30 10:39:11 UTC
Hello, Phate:

I suggest you GOING YOUR DOCTOR and explain your problems about the calcium sources. Possibly, he/she`ll give you a complete food plan to take the calcium in other ways, for example: calcium supplements.

I tell you something. I had to take calcium supplement due to my Precocious menopause.



Gordi :-)
vegetable
2007-07-30 10:34:24 UTC
Cows get calcium from the food they eat. When cows used to graze, it came from grass. Now that they are forced to live in feedlots, they get their calcium from supplements.

You can get enough calcium from plant sources.
2017-02-17 04:35:21 UTC
It will depend on the fruit or plant involved with a comparison. In the event you compare a farreneheit to a carrot, the carrot is the better of the two nutritional. But once you compare an avocado to the carrot, then an avocado is better. Both equally the apple and avocado, are fruits.
abafna
2007-07-31 00:20:06 UTC
Well come to the world of vegetarian because of you more and more animals will save their lives thanks,please dont eat any animals products also eggs & fish are non-veg

Proteins: Body's protein needs can be provided by either animal or plant sources. Mixed protein diet obtained from various plant sources is better than animal protein and is recommended in diabetes, renal diseases and liver diseases. Mixed protein diet from different plant sources has been the pattern of diet in India for all vegetarians.



Carbohydrates: Carbohydrates are mainly found in plant foods; like cereals, grains, fresh and dry fruits, legumes, vegetable, greens, nuts etc. plant carbohydrates include' large amounts of starches, sugar and fibers which are important for gut functions. The body is better suited to a high carbohydrate diet than a low carbohydrate diet. In fact 55% of the food intake should be carbohydrate. All animal products do not contain carbohydrate which is essential for body.



Fat: Plant fats differ from animal fats in two different ways 1) they are cholesterol free 2) they generally contain more polyunsaturated fat and less saturated fats. Plant fats usually have higher polyunsaturated fat value than animal fats.



A diet which is low in cholesterol and which contains fat of a high PIS value is associated with a lower incident of coronary health disease.



Vitamins and Minerals: plant foods are rich in many vitamins and minerals.



Vitamin D: Vitamin D is obtained by exposure of skin to sun light and this is not a problem in India.



Calcium: The vegetarians can meet their needs for calcium from dairy products. Riboflavin (Vitamin B2) Dark green vegetables are good sources of Riboflavin as are legumes and whole grain cereal.



Iron: The problem of iron deficiency is relatively common but vitamin C significantly enhances absorption of iron hence it is advisable for vegetarians to include with each meal a food high in vitamin C which as lime, citrus fruits or juices.



Zinc: Zinc is found in large number of plant foods.



Fiber: Fiber is found only in vegetarian food like whole grain cereals, legumes, greens, fruits, vegetable etc.



Thus in vegetarian foods all requirement of nutrition for body growth and maintenance is fulfilled. One can have a complete and balanced diet provided we take enough food which is as close to nature as possible in maintaining sturdy and disease free body. It is equally helpful in curing many diseases.



ADVANTAGES OF VEGETARIAN DIET:

More & more evidence is surfacing that directly links a prolonged non- vegetarian diet to diseases as cancers, heart diseases, diabetes, asthma just to name a few.



1. LOGEVITY: Vegetarian can expect to live 4-10 years longer then the non-vegetarians.



" Source: Seventh day Adventists study



2. LESS HEART DISEASE: Because of low fat, saturated fat and cholesterol content of the vegetarian diet the risk of heart disease is lowered. High blood cholesterol levels are associated with increased risk of heart disease.



3. LESS CANCER: Up to 40% of all cancers are diet related. Cancer death rates have been associated with obesity and high fat / low fiber diet. Vitamin A & C are thought to be protective against colon cancer. Low fat diets protect against prostrate and breast cancer. Indoles, lignans, isoflavones, protease inhibitors which are present in plant foods and shown to be potent anti carcinogens.



4. LESS BOWEL DISEASE: Diverticular disease and appendicitis occur more frequently with low fiber intake as in meat diet.



5. LEES OBESITY & LESS INCIDENCE OF DIABETES: It is easier to plan a low fat diet for a vegetarian then for a meat eater. The fiber in plant food dilutes the energy & provides a satisfying meal without all the calories. Diabetes over the age of 40 seems to be related to obesity.


This content was originally posted on Y! Answers, a Q&A website that shut down in 2021.
Continue reading on narkive:
Loading...